GamingSins: Everything Wrong with Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor

Над видео могла бы быть ваша реклама.
2699 ratings | 107547 views
Под видео могла бы быть ваша реклама.


GamingSins: Everything Wrong with Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor

Welcome to GamingSins, where I nitpick the hell out of video games. Today, I sin Shadow of Mordor.an average game with a really cool mechanic that got a lot more praise than it deserves. I suppose it would be an amazing game if your standards aren't that high. But to everyone else, it's just a typical action adventure, AAA game. Now if you're a hardcore LOTR fan, this might just be a badly written fan fiction. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- If you wish to support Jaki Rose and download the end credit 'Video Game Song' . And of course, don't forget to check out The Originals, CinemaSins.

Comments to the video: GamingSins: Everything Wrong with Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor

GCN 5 months ago
Taking a break from Mass Effect Andromeda. WAY too many other games to cover right now.
guyver 5er 1 month ago
GCN but the game is based around stealth, there's a whole gameplay aspect about it and abilities that support it and give you bonuses for doing such, you gave one too many sins
Lennon Barry 1 month ago
GCN hey fuck you the combat is really fun. Your standards are way too high
Cherif Tekouk 1 month ago
+Brandon Hall he regreted everything in P1 and they made him a villain in P2 why?
Cherif Tekouk 1 month ago
do GTA SA please
the blue psycho 2 months ago
You really need it I Twitter by the way
Donovan DeLozier 6 hours ago
This game doesn't say celebrimbor forged the one ring, merely that he adjusted it so it didn't shine as a massive beacon of power at all times.
Black Ice 3 days ago
One other fad that needs to fade away: teabagging.
laylaruan 11 days ago
3:25 Australian ? What?
Jeff 15 days ago
I hate finding and picking herbs during the heat of battle, health potions would've been nice😫
Kristian Kember 16 days ago
try the game asura's wrath lol
Lucina the bloodlustful reploid 18 days ago
3:26 you sounded like kano from MKX i applaud you +1 like
WithinMy Shadows 20 days ago
only counter point is the nemesis rng system only because my ultimate nemesis started as a grunt who got a lucky hit and came back from death twice..i was satisfied to behead him in the final battle. but again that was just my play-through
nik Bahtin 1 month ago
dunno still like it better then the shadow of war
Trey Smith 1 month ago
1:25 But a large part of this game is stealth based.
Donovan DeLozier 1 month ago
going to nitpick your nitpick, at 24:38 you said that apparently Celebrimbor forged the one ring in this timeline, when the game makes no such assertion, it states very clearly that Sauron crafted the ring. The game goes on to say that Celebrimbor made the adjustment to the ring which makes its wearer invisible and keeps the huge amount of power within it from constantly glowing.
woolfallcrescent170 1 month ago
Gcn? The books were written in English. Try and at least pronounce the names in English? Not some bastard American drivel.Well props to gcn, he actually played this one. Shocking I know!But that is all the complementary writing he shall get.Why do you try and be controversial? You comment on games you know to be excellent, give them your pathetic sins and bask in the adolescent fan love?Oh right, I forgot you have the iq of a stale tampon.For any true gamers, shadow of mordor is excellent, it's nemesis system is revolutionary and the story line follows in parallel to the semiarion.
GeekyQuinn 1 month ago
Why the hell does Talion sound like Chris Hemsworth's version of Thor? I dunno whether to class that as a sin or not.
Okuma kyoukabe 1 month ago
He failed as the one ring was messed with by sauron
Veloziraptor111 1 month ago
You forgot to sin the Tower fight as well. Definitely the most awesome looking of the three Black Captains, and yet, his boss fight is a super easy and gimmicky stealth segment. To say that it was disappointing would be an understatement.
Guilherme Bastos 1 month ago
7:13 did you play any attention to the mission you were playing?
GhostCell47 1 month ago
Man-swine!! Shall I say goodbye? When you fall and die! After I pluck out your eye!!
Daniel Gibeault 1 month ago
21:15 😂😂😂😂😂
KineticRhyme 1 month ago
But Persona 3 has a protagonist that had amnesia, along with his robot lover. And yet it turned out to be a rather good plot.
Robert Harmon 1 month ago
When are you going to to shadow of war? Or you're waiting for all DLC to be released?
billybob thorton 1 month ago
22:53 Actually, my nemesis I killed 4 times before that final fight, including a decapitation believe it or not, so that part of the game deserves a sin for my playthrough, but a different one
Nunya Business 1 month ago
This is still one of the greatest games ever!
Bob Lucci 1 month ago
If we’re being fair it’s middle earth so it’s not an Australian accent
Winter Weasel 1 month ago
sin 73 they are talking about talion talion was a gondorian ranger, enemies of the renegades of mordor and thus a few weeks ago he would have been an enemy
Christoffer Olsen 1 month ago
19:14 the bule eyes are just a gameplay thing
Shaco Alon 1 month ago
GCN Celebrimbor wasn't making the one he was concealing its power
Shaco Alon 1 month ago
Elves are immortal if they DIDN'T train to fight that'd just be laziness
Shaco Alon 1 month ago
Am I only one who hears Celebrimbor not mispronounce anything
the blue psycho 2 months ago
You need a Twitter
Nathaniel Moore 2 months ago
You asked for some form of market.You got one in SOW
Plinky Plonk 2 months ago
I know you guys don’t hate every game you sin and I personally loved this video and all your others but until Shadow of War came out this was my most favourite game of ALL time, I loved the way you shat on this game but if you guys were to ever sin Shadow of War try and be a little more sensitive.
Izzy plays 2 months ago
No hate but why are you just copying off of cinema sins? I know you are doing video games but still
Renaissance Man 2 months ago
I fucking HATE HATE all these goddam quick time events they RUIN games
flyingnoodle 2 months ago
now that i watch this i realize that there was some MAJOR foreshadowing to the plot twist at the end of SOW
Haydn Barnes 2 months ago
If I didn't play the game before I would have genuinely thought he was one of the voice actors haha well done you beautiful bastard 😂
Plinky Plonk 2 months ago
23:00 tell that to Shakâ Ghul Hunter
Fuyutsuru 2 months ago
Sin Okami next!
Samuel Baxter 2 months ago
I'm surprised that he did not sin the fact that you never actually get an orc army, It's just the warchiefs
Samuel Baxter 2 months ago
My game actually glitched out and would not spawn graugs outside main story mission.
mrwonderful7074 2 months ago
LJN GAMES. SIN
LobbyVictor 2 months ago
Shadow of mordor is just a ripoff of Assassin's creed, lord of the rings, batman arkam night and prince of persia
Nameless Drake 2 months ago
That combat system is what made it famous whatsoever
Boris Müller 2 months ago
This guy misunderstands this game.
Mr.fruit roll up Gameplay 3 months ago
Actually bagabug skull bow was my nemesis and he defeated me many times
Jake Bryant 3 months ago
This is a non canon story
Jaikhem Lambert 3 months ago
It's nonfiction
slashdead 02 3 months ago
Done that game branded every one and got all the skills too
Brian Ogilby 3 months ago
Middle Earth Shadow Of Ripping Off The Better Assasins Creed Mordor. This games a joke.
ThePreatoriann 3 months ago
Funny, I counted 40
Austin Vander Heide 3 months ago
Nah nah nah nah nah, the Rhymers and Singers are worth 5 sins off EACH.
Redon Duko 3 months ago
You should have put more sins at the final boss being quick time events because my interest in that game got lost and fuck you developers for doing that you make a Captain sound more challenging than the final boss
ji ribu 3 months ago
1:20 i disagree , thicc-ness dropped over the years , also clothing she is wearing also contributes to the thicc-ness. sry bro but its school level of anatomy.
sean rogers 3 months ago
You should add an extra sin for sins that were in the previous game and also in the sequel because they couldn't be bothered to learn from their mistakes.
Oskand 3 months ago
Take back sin number 6 cause this game is based around stealth
The Omega-Mancer 3 months ago
That ending was super disappointing for me. The Tower was a stealth segment, when he could've put up an awesome mental duel (akin to Sasha from inFamous), the final boss is a QUICKTIME EVENT, and it just seems sort of unintelligible.
Slishes Maloney 3 months ago
Why didn't they have Trolls and Wargs in this game? Was it because of copyright problems? If so, why do Graugs and Caragors look exactly like Trolls and Wargs, respectivey?
Daniel Cole 3 months ago
24:56 Sense of pride nor accomplishment. I really hope that's a jab at EA
John Clarke 4 months ago
You really name all the irritating aspects of the game that stopped me from finishing it. I thought it was just me.
Templar Death93 4 months ago
3:23 trust an american to mix up an Australian accent with a brittish one
hak525 4 months ago
You talk about Baker, but Jeniffer Hale has pretty much given her voice to any important female character in the past 15 years
Izicial 4 months ago
Someone should sin this reskin of cinema sins :D
That Guy Awesome 4 months ago
so, my nemesis was this dude, Olgoth the messenger, he killed me while a grunt and got promoted, i killed him once with stealth (he was vulnerable) and he came back to life with this large metal spike on his head, just a FEW meters away from where i killed him and about 1 minute AFTER i did kill him, i killed him in story yet he still lived in the game mode for this game called Nemesis Forge i eventually branded him and he was the guy transferred from this game to the new one, Shadow of War
Processed Human 4 months ago
We're at the point where literally anything in the game is worthy of a sin. Might as well just switch to movies and COMPLETELY undercut CinemaSins.
Jordan Garcia 4 months ago
Uh, how does he get resurrected after he dies. Like.a lot of uruks say they'll dismember him if they kill him. If they do how is he resurrected completely intact? Fuck you, that's how
Requiem Solace 4 months ago
I hate seeing this dumb shit in gaming threads and youtube, people constantly complain about games stealing shit from other games, as if that somehow make a game bad, a lot of games rip-off of each other. And ripping off something is not a bad thing, it helps to progress games forward. I bought shadows of mordor because I love lotr. For a fanboy like me this game is great, I really don't see how people can find the most dumb shit to blow out of proportion and complain about, especially when they don't own the game. When devs do dumb shit like the micro-transactions fiasco on Battlefront 2 they deserve to get hate, but when a company makes a game that gets it right , they deserve some praise.
Cosmin29 2 months ago
If you take this channel seriously (and since you are a fanboy of a game you will), then you should get off this channel and never go back. Just because he makes a video on a game doesn't mean he thinks it's bad. And no praise should be given for microtransactions in a singleplayer game.
Brian Ogilby 3 months ago
Ripping off is never good. Paying homage to is good. Theres a big difference between doing that to something and ripping something off.
Requiem Solace 4 months ago
Does that make the game any less enjoyable?....no, and the point I an trying to make is that most games copy other games mechanics, its not that big of a deal especially if the game is a success and builds upon the game mechanic that it copied. When Shadows of Mordor came out Ubisoft(who is know for downgrading their games and making fun of gamers who voiced their opinion about, remember resolutiongate) quickly went to work trying to make a mockery out of the the game, just because they built the climbing and running animations from AC, and as much as ubisoft wants to believe that they were the first build that parkour mechanic, they probably stole that mechanic from another lesser known game franchise or book series. People need to stop being hipsters, and blowing every little thing out of proportion.
CJG G 4 months ago
Hielo Fuego There is a difference from taking inspiration from a mechanic and basically copy and pasting it.
LupineShadowOmega 4 months ago
To be fair, all Peter Jackson Elves are immaculate combat ninjas. XD
Papa Thicc 4 months ago
FUUUUUCK THIS GAAAAME
Brian Ogilby 3 months ago
Agreed.
Sorex112 4 months ago
21:47 If you know what I mean. When you're done.
Lorian Ebonheart 4 months ago
In the shadows story the rings where all forged by quelebrimbor , and he even perfected the one ring.
WINDEX GLASS CLEANER 4 months ago
You do realize goroth is premade and is made to have that weakness right?
Kedarrius Simpson 4 months ago
u did not just say the batman arkahm series' combat mechanic was mediocre, we gotta throw hands now bro
MrPeopleftw 4 months ago
Another nitpicking video, great
M. Victor Howard 4 months ago
This game is stealth based.
LegionFunGamerWorks2 5 months ago
PLUS 1 SIN.RUINING J R R TOLKIENS lore
Soul Fox32 5 months ago
3:30 Wow really?! You did an accent better than most Orcs in game WTF?!
Ortu Ignis 5 months ago
Ugh this channel is getting lazy. they also don't seem to know LotR lore.
Cosmin29 2 months ago
How is it getting lazy?
leonardo jose molina mora 5 months ago
50% of this game is stealth. so I don't know your wrong thing, and if u want to create a new type of fight, u do it and stop to complain.
TheBigDstudios 5 months ago
@12:05 ever heard of torturing someone for information?
OG WP 5 months ago
For the Graug sin, the Graug that you meet in the cave is immune to arrows and so you can't kill it that easily.
Bryan Mitchum 5 months ago
Dude sound like Wesker lol
Ninjastahr 5 months ago
The game is *sorta* stealth-based, depending on how you play.
Paweł Mulak 5 months ago
You realize that whole amnesia thing was a lie?
Kai Leng 5 months ago
Why is this shit even here? the new game is out
Stefi Zdravkovic 5 months ago
Just 26 minuts
Komedy Things 5 months ago
Sin Hidden Agenda
Scooter Is My Bae 5 months ago
Can you do everything wrong with road of the dead and road of the dead 2 pls ?
Ian Baer 5 months ago
The Nemesis system is why i got an Xbox One so i can see it in its full glory. Fucking incredible system
Brandon Lamb 5 months ago
Do a video for Mafia 2
Joseph Mestas 5 months ago
Uncharted 3? 4? Sorry man luv you're channel but I have always enjoyed the uncharted games and to have them being nitpick the hell out of is amazing.
Arima 5 months ago
DO DISHONORED 2 PLEASE!!!!!!!!
BLU Storm 5 months ago
Doom2016
Thomas Johnson 5 months ago
i agree with some of this, but its clear you didn't pay attention at all, Gorgoroth is afraid of caragors and he is a caragor tamer, that was the point, he acted tough but was a wimp, ratbag told you this, that was the slightly funny point 8:27 you realize you was fucking with ratbag right, also uruks aren't that smart, he wouldn't know the definition of a duel. 8:40 dude come on, THAT WAS THE FUCKING JOKE 9:05 THAT'S THE FUCKING JOKE AND RATBAG DIDN'T KNOW THAT, YOU JUST ACT LIKE HE KNOWS FUTURE INFORMATION AND AREN'T PAYING ATTENTION. 9:54 i would say choking someone is a attempt or at the very least threat on their life. 10:30, i don't see a problem with this. 10:49 for one ratbag is kind of stupid, 2, you didn't mention this when the plan first started, 3, you could get killed any second as a lowly Uruk, especially if your not a uruk-hai, he will have protectors and intimidation on his side as a warcheif, plus talion could help him. 11:51 didn't realize you cant have a random ass person look slightly similar to a character from a game made more than 3 years ago. 12:02 oh i don't know, the normal FUCKING WAY TO INTERROGATE SOMEONE, INTIMIDATION, TORTURE, ITS NOT THAT HARD TO GUESS IF YOU TRY. 13:40 and you know this how? 14:02 seriously dude, characters don't know everything, they know what they know, they didn't know that the black captains were searching for them. 14:23 actually ratbag was dead but was resurrected by a necromancer, but what should i expect, you don't pay attention to the story. 14:43 i don't know, literally any fucking ranger that he didn't personally kill. 14:58 so? people have nicknames, but you usually don't call someone them what shit gets serious. 15:29 that makes sense, he wouldn't have any incentive to go if he wasn't interested. 15:40 for one lets be honest here, you would have complained if there was no fast travel because the map was so big, 2 you literally have the power to fast travel because of your wraith abilities, so its not like its just bullshit, its literally magic. 18:40 *sigh* OK first off torvin doesn't know hes part wraith, also he probably thinks its a fine comparison, he probably thinks his dog was amazing and clearly doesn't believe talion has the fighting prowess, but again you wouldn't know that because you dont pay attention to story 19:05 i slightly agree but then again you have to realise, or i wish you would realize that torvin doesnt know he has these magic wraith powers. 19:14 *sigh* uruks oblviously cant see the blue face or hand when there not branded, so obviously only you can see the glowing blue hand. 20:15 i dont even understand how this is a sin, he hoped that they would cross again, which they did in the dlc, but its a sin for the sequel not having him, which is wrong by the way, baranors dlc will have them. 20:32, thats the whole point of having a warcheif branded, the grunts don't know or don't care because they are fighting, the warcheif could easily go, YEAH LETS KILL SAURON CUZ WERE COOLER AND STRONGER. 20:40 yeah that makes sense, he was focusing on getting celebrimor, i would imagine you would be distracted when your about ot complete your life goal. 22:30 are you serious, talion literally fucking answers the question right there, but whoopty doo what a suprise you dont pay attention to the story 23:30 because she was fucking under saurons control, why would talion have belived anything she said after that PAY ATTENTION. 24:39, hes probably not because this game isn't canon, it just tries to stay close to it. 25:35 i would hope so, considering they wanted to MAKE A FUCKING SEQUEL
Oliver Mavlappas 5 months ago
Thomas Johnson I agree
Ridojimo Arika 5 months ago
23:16 Dude, look at his mouth. You can't spell certain letters without lips such as ''b'' and he spelled the word Celebrimbor so well. I'd sin that. +4 :)
Colton poppell 5 months ago
Id love to see y’all sin MK Shaolin Monks, that shit would be amazing!!!!
MarineC1 5 months ago
In my opinion he sequel is so much better and is one of my favourite games of this year and maybe all time
Nassir Rose 5 months ago
Fuck you
CJG G 4 months ago
Nassir Rose Nice argument
Tyler Huntress 5 months ago
Regarding Talion being Hirgon and Eryn's enemy as of a few weeks before the story, that was by virtue of him still being a Ranger and Hirgon and Eryn being outcasts.
Mata Nui 5 months ago
The nemesis system is really overrated as it odesn't do anything all that special.
Mata Nui 5 months ago
The stealth system was actually pretty good in this game.
Sora Takushima 5 months ago
Everything wrong with Beyond Good And Evil